Compare and Contrast Bernini and Michelangelo David Sculptures Paper
300 word minimum essay in MLA format, describe and analyze two works from the two periods (Baroque and Renaisaance) by comparing and contrasting the works using your Principles of Art sheet, and also including the Context, cultural influences affecting each work.
Topic ( A) : COMPARE AND CONTRAST TWO SCULPTURES
Compare and contrast Bernini’s David
with Michelangelo’s David
Do the works share some commonalities (such as the same subject matter). What else may be similar? How are they alike (compare), and how do they differ (contrast)? What are some key points? What aspect of each artwork does the artist emphasize in his work? What effect on the viewer, if any? How does each work represent the style and flavor of their representative cultural period (context). Consider everything when you analyze each work, but concentrate on the most pertinent points.
These principles of art should help:
OUTLINE:PRINCIPLES OF VISUAL ART
I.SUBJECT (not essential – may be abstracted or non-representational)
What is the work of art about?Common sources of art subjects:
Nature (including humans)
History
Greek and Roman mythology
The (Jewish) and Christian Tradition / Oriental sacred texts
Fantasy, Dreams, Subconscious
Other works of art
II.FUNCTION (not essential)
What is it for?
Directly practical and useful art/ the “applied” arts/ crafts?
III. MEDIUM
What is it made of?
For example, in painting the medium my be oil, watercolor, fresco . . .
In sculpture, the medium may be marble or wood
IV. ELEMENTS AND ORGANIZATION – How is it put together?
Elements:
Line – vertical (potential action, authority), horizontal (rest, contemplation), diagonal (action, movement), curving (life, energy, a gentle action)
Light and shadow (chiaroscuro?)
Color
Texture- how it feels to the touch(in painting it is an illusion)
Volume / Space
Including perspective – physical in architecture- in painting is an illusion
Organization:
Basic Plans (the “form” / “overall design”/ arrangement of parts
Triangular, circular, rectangular
Balance- symmetrical (mirror-image) or asymmetrical
Proportion – parts to the whole
Unity and Variety
V.REALISM / IDEALISM / or ABSTRACTION (at what level?)
VI. STYLE
What is its mood, temper, personality? Artists, movements, schools, historical periods, cultures produce identifiable styles that have a “look”
“Classic” vs. “Romantic” (non-classical)
VII. SYMBOLS – personal or archetypal
VIII. JUDGEMENT
Is individual and personal. Consider: What has the artist tried to do? Does the work express the character of the age? Levels of meaning? Petty or Sublime (spiritually moving